ABC/HR for Java, Version 0.5b, 07 January 2006 Testname: ravel Tester: Erik 1R = Sample13\ravel_5.wav 2L = Sample13\ravel_3.wav 3R = Sample13\ravel_6.wav 4R = Sample13\ravel_4.wav 5L = Sample13\ravel_2.wav 6L = Sample13\ravel_1.wav --------------------------------------- General Comments: listening to quiet and fast attacks at 12.8-15.8 sec Three of the codecs are too close to tell apart. Two are slightly worse. --------------------------------------- 1R File: Sample13\ravel_5.wav 1R Rating: 4.2 1R Comment: this is the worst one --------------------------------------- 2L File: Sample13\ravel_3.wav 2L Rating: 4.3 2L Comment: second worst. but very close --------------------------------------- 3R File: Sample13\ravel_6.wav 3R Rating: 4.8 3R Comment: --------------------------------------- 4R File: Sample13\ravel_4.wav 4R Rating: 1.0 4R Comment: --------------------------------------- 5L File: Sample13\ravel_2.wav 5L Rating: 4.8 5L Comment: --------------------------------------- 6L File: Sample13\ravel_1.wav 6L Rating: 4.7 6L Comment: possibly a bit worse than the other two but couldn't verify through abx --------------------------------------- ABX Results: Original vs Sample13\ravel_5.wav 7 out of 8, pval = 0.035 Original vs Sample13\ravel_6.wav 13 out of 18, pval = 0.048 Original vs Sample13\ravel_1.wav 14 out of 18, pval = 0.015 Original vs Sample13\ravel_2.wav 13 out of 18, pval = 0.048 Original vs Sample13\ravel_3.wav 11 out of 11, pval < 0.001 ---- Detailed ABX results ---- Original vs Sample13\ravel_5.wav Playback Range: 12.848 to 15.814 2:31:48 PM f 0/1 pval = 1.0 2:31:52 PM p 1/2 pval = 0.75 2:31:56 PM p 2/3 pval = 0.5 2:32:34 PM p 3/4 pval = 0.312 2:32:39 PM p 4/5 pval = 0.187 2:32:43 PM p 5/6 pval = 0.109 2:33:17 PM p 6/7 pval = 0.062 2:33:28 PM p 7/8 pval = 0.035 Original vs Sample13\ravel_6.wav Playback Range: 12.848 to 15.769 2:12:18 PM p 1/1 pval = 0.5 2:12:22 PM p 2/2 pval = 0.25 2:12:35 PM p 3/3 pval = 0.125 2:12:40 PM p 4/4 pval = 0.062 2:12:45 PM p 5/5 pval = 0.031 2:12:50 PM p 6/6 pval = 0.015 2:12:53 PM p 7/7 pval = 0.0070 2:12:58 PM p 8/8 pval = 0.0030 2:13:03 PM f 8/9 pval = 0.019 2:13:06 PM f 8/10 pval = 0.054 2:13:10 PM p 9/11 pval = 0.032 2:13:17 PM f 9/12 pval = 0.072 2:13:21 PM f 9/13 pval = 0.133 2:13:26 PM p 10/14 pval = 0.089 2:13:31 PM p 11/15 pval = 0.059 2:13:35 PM p 12/16 pval = 0.038 2:13:46 PM p 13/17 pval = 0.024 2:13:50 PM f 13/18 pval = 0.048 Original vs Sample13\ravel_1.wav Playback Range: 12.848 to 15.769 3:52:55 PM p 1/1 pval = 0.5 3:53:40 PM f 1/2 pval = 0.75 3:53:54 PM f 1/3 pval = 0.875 3:54:12 PM p 2/4 pval = 0.687 3:54:17 PM p 3/5 pval = 0.5 3:54:21 PM p 4/6 pval = 0.343 3:54:25 PM p 5/7 pval = 0.226 3:54:33 PM p 6/8 pval = 0.144 3:54:38 PM p 7/9 pval = 0.089 3:55:02 PM p 8/10 pval = 0.054 3:55:16 PM p 9/11 pval = 0.032 3:55:22 PM p 10/12 pval = 0.019 3:55:42 PM f 10/13 pval = 0.046 3:55:46 PM p 11/14 pval = 0.028 3:55:59 PM p 12/15 pval = 0.017 3:56:04 PM p 13/16 pval = 0.01 3:56:19 PM p 14/17 pval = 0.0060 3:56:38 PM f 14/18 pval = 0.015 Original vs Sample13\ravel_2.wav Playback Range: 12.848 to 15.769 2:06:57 PM f 0/1 pval = 1.0 2:07:01 PM p 1/2 pval = 0.75 2:07:06 PM p 2/3 pval = 0.5 2:07:11 PM f 2/4 pval = 0.687 2:07:15 PM p 3/5 pval = 0.5 2:07:19 PM p 4/6 pval = 0.343 2:07:23 PM f 4/7 pval = 0.5 2:07:27 PM p 5/8 pval = 0.363 2:07:32 PM p 6/9 pval = 0.253 2:07:36 PM p 7/10 pval = 0.171 2:07:44 PM p 8/11 pval = 0.113 2:07:52 PM p 9/12 pval = 0.072 2:07:57 PM f 9/13 pval = 0.133 2:08:02 PM p 10/14 pval = 0.089 2:08:07 PM p 11/15 pval = 0.059 2:08:12 PM p 12/16 pval = 0.038 2:08:22 PM f 12/17 pval = 0.071 2:08:29 PM p 13/18 pval = 0.048 Original vs Sample13\ravel_3.wav Playback Range: 12.848 to 15.814 2:20:45 PM p 1/1 pval = 0.5 2:21:11 PM p 2/2 pval = 0.25 2:21:15 PM p 3/3 pval = 0.125 2:21:20 PM p 4/4 pval = 0.062 2:21:24 PM p 5/5 pval = 0.031 2:21:36 PM p 6/6 pval = 0.015 2:23:00 PM p 7/7 pval = 0.0070 2:23:03 PM p 8/8 pval = 0.0030 2:23:44 PM p 9/9 pval = 0.0010 2:23:52 PM p 10/10 pval < 0.001 2:24:16 PM p 11/11 pval < 0.001